An empty Emo & Mall Pop-Punk stage, waiting for your band

2002–2008 · emo · pop punk · post-hardcore

The all-time Emo & Mall Pop-Punk supergroup

Black eyeliner, Warped Tour and songs about your ex with a breakdown in the middle. My Chemical Romance, Paramore, Fall Out Boy and Panic! at the Disco went from MySpace pages to arenas in about three years. The scene's own lifers beat borrowed stars every time.

Draft a Emo & Mall Pop-Punk band →

Free, no login. Hear your band play when the last seat is filled.

The favourites

  • lead vocal Gerard Way
  • guitar Joe Trohman
  • bass Jeremy Davis
  • drums Spencer Smith

Draft the top name in each seat (one per band, same as the game) and SGOAT gives them a C. Great players, wrong band. You can do better.

Best Emo & Mall Pop-Punk singers

  1. Gerard Way · My Chemical Romance
  2. Hayley Williams · Paramore
  3. Patrick Stump · Fall Out Boy
  4. Brendon Urie · Panic! at the Disco
  5. Anthony Green · Saosin

Best Emo & Mall Pop-Punk guitarists

  1. Ray Toro · My Chemical Romance
  2. Frank Iero · My Chemical Romance
  3. Joe Trohman · Fall Out Boy
  4. Josh Farro · Paramore
  5. Ryan Ross · Panic! at the Disco

Best Emo & Mall Pop-Punk bassists

  1. Pete Wentz · Fall Out Boy
  2. Mikey Way · My Chemical Romance
  3. Jeremy Davis · Paramore
  4. Garrett Tierney · Brand New

Best Emo & Mall Pop-Punk drummers

  1. Andy Hurley · Fall Out Boy
  2. Zac Farro · Paramore
  3. Spencer Smith · Panic! at the Disco
  4. Aaron Gillespie

Our picks, in our order. Think we’ve got it wrong? Draft your own band and prove it.

Draft your own Emo & Mall Pop-Punk band →

More scenes

2000s RevivalBlog-Era IndieAll 30 scenesToday’s daily draft

← Back to SGOAT